Troubleshooting is part art, part science, pure and simple. Troubleshooting is also universal: Whether it is electrical, mechanical, or something else, the same concepts will always apply.
You must learn three elements of troubleshooting:
- Patience. It takes time to troubleshoot, and you may find yourself at the point of complete frustration, but hang in there; as you narrow the search, the light will get brighter.
- Understanding. Many of the systems you troubleshoot will be different. You may troubleshoot a breaker control scheme one day and an operational control system the next. Despite how different these systems may be, the troubleshooting process will essentially be the same.
- Thinking outside the box. Don’t assume that troubleshooting will require a single, conventional solution. There will be times when you will think of something totally unrelated, yet it will give you the clue to solving this problem.
RULES
Next are certain rules that apply to basic troubleshooting:
- Rule One. You must know how the failed system should have worked. If you don’t know how it works, take the time to investigate the technical documentation and drawings, or ask on-site personnel how they believe it should work. Remember, the only dumb question is the one that is not asked.
- Rule Two. The majority of your testing will not be done on the equipment itself. Rather, it will be on paper, suggesting possible issues, prior history, or even hearsay. Your goal is to create a hypothesis, or hypotheses, that can be tested.
- Rule Three. This is an important one—you must try to prove your hypothesis is wrong. Most technicians troubleshoot by trying to prove their hypothesis correct, and when a test proves otherwise, they begin to believe the test itself was wrong. Then they go try to prove their hypothesis is correct with a different test. This only wastes time and builds frustration. Hypotheses need to be tested to failure. You may not have the right idea at first, but as stated by Sherlock Holmes, “When you have eliminated the impossible, whatever remains, however improbable, must be the truth.”
- Rule Four. You must have good test equipment—calibrated and ready for use. Using poor test equipment can lead you down a black hole and waste an enormous amount of time. For example, if you are looking for continuity, make sure that your meter works both before and after you test.
- Rule Five. Use your resources. Listen to those who have tested the equipment before. Find out what their experience level is and what they have tested. If you trust their ability, then you have a ready source of information that will enable you to narrow down your search criteria.
- Rule Six. Document everything. Write it down and take photos. Do not leave room for uncertainty. Doubts may surface unless you have proof.
GATHERING INFORMATION
The next part of troubleshooting will be the Who-What-Why-Where and How of testing. These five Ws are not just for journalism; this will provide key information for your troubleshooting techniques.

- Who was present during the failure? You will need to know who that individual is as well as their partiality and reliability. Case in point: If they were disgruntled, could they have caused the issue(s)? What can they tell you about what was going on and what indications they experienced? Record this information as it may prove useful later.
- What was going on at the time of failure? Was the equipment starting, stopping, running, or just sitting idle? All these points are important in helping you determine which part of the equipment to start your investigation with.
- Why did it fail? Is the equipment 50 years old and already on the brink of failure? Or could it have failed because something new was introduced? You may not be able to answer this question, but defining a problem is the halfway point to finding a solution.
- Where in the equipment did the failure occur? You may think this also involves equipment in motion.
- How did it fail? Did a $3,000 part fail to protect a $3.00 fuse? Did a mechanical problem create an electrical problem or vice versa?
These questions can take as little as 10 minutes, but the information they provide will help you narrow down the scope of the investigation. Remember, these are just suggestions that may or may not apply. Sometimes the issue will be as obvious as a large smoking hole in the equipment where you can see the short-circuit damage.
PREPARE
Now that you have spent the time gathering the findings, let’s look at what you need to do to continue the troubleshooting.
- Gather all available drawings. These are critical because they help you understand where to look further. Experience has shown that many customers don’t have the drawings that were provided years ago.
- Gather all test data that may have been performed on the equipment. If you see a pattern, you may be able to narrow down your search area.
- Use paper! Write down everything you see or think might be the issue. This also enables others to see your thought process and offer ideas. Don’t dismiss their ideas, as they may be the ones who can see the forest through the trees. Remember, the longer you troubleshoot, the more likely you are to dig yourself into a trench you cannot see out of.

SIX-STEP TROUBLESHOOTING METHOD
- Identify the problem. This was done when you answered the Who-What-Why-Where-How.
- Establish a theory of probable cause. This is your first attempt at troubleshooting. You will write down ideas of what you believe could have caused the problem. Remember: Human elements may be the cause of the issue.
- Test the theory to determine the cause. This is where you prove your theory wrong. If you keep trying to prove yourself right, you may become frustrated and waste valuable time, instead of accepting that the original idea you came up with is wrong.
- Establish a plan of action and implement the solution. This is the stage of the process where you must test your ideas. Sometimes it is as simple as determining that the fuse blew. Now you must address the question of WHY the fuse has blown. Sometimes we answer the question only to find new ones hiding behind them. Please also remember: If you are replacing parts, check to be sure you are not installing an old failed part. Blown fuses can wind up back in the new fuses box, so double-check them before you install.
- Verify full system functionality. After you fix the problem, you must verify that the solution works. Don’t just assume that you are done and walk away. You might get a call back in a few minutes/hours/days to say it still doesn’t work.
- Document findings, actions, and outcomes. No job is complete until the paperwork is done. This critical step includes the following:
a. Document the findings of what failed and why it caused the issue. The customer will want to justify the expense of having hired you to troubleshoot the issue.
b. This paperwork can be used later to confirm that the issue was corrected or if there is now an underlying issue that will cause this issue to occur again.
c. This document can also be used to teach others about a particular issue or used as a reference should additional problems occur with the equipment.
Typically, electrical issues are difficult to find but easy to fix, while mechanical issues are usually easy to detect but painful to fix. Every troubleshooting adventure is also a training lesson, not only for you, but for the next technician as well.
If you are just learning to troubleshoot, adopting this policy might help you: When you have an issue, take at least 15 minutes to work through the issue yourself. Don’t take more than 30 minutes, though, because at that point you may find yourself in that trench we mentioned earlier. Also consider reaching out to experienced colleagues who can help you gain insight into the issue.
CONCLUSION
No one becomes a troubleshooting expert overnight. It will take time to build your knowledge base so you can see patterns in failures. Be patient with yourself as you build the knowledge and skills to deeply understand the systems and equipment you will be working on. Finally, thinking outside the box allows for creative solutions to difficult troubleshooting problems.

Timothy Shaw is VP of Operations for Mark Thomas and Associates (MTA) Electrical Engineers. After serving in the U.S. Navy for 20 years and retiring as an EMC(SS), Shaw worked for Electrical Reliability Services for almost 15 years before joining MTA. He is a NETA Level 4 Certified Technician and has been in the industry since 2003.
