IEEE C57.166-2026: A New Unified Guide for the Acceptance and Maintenance of Transformer Insulating Liquids

Scott Reed, MVACorporate Alliance Corner, Winter 2026 Corporate Alliance Corner

The publication of IEEE C57.166-2026, Guide for Acceptance and Maintenance of Insulating Liquids in Transformers and Related Equipment, represents a significant change in how the industry evaluates and maintains insulating liquids. Rather than maintaining separate guides for individual liquid types, C57.166 brings the principal transformer insulating liquids into a single document and, importantly, updates much of the technical guidance used to evaluate liquids in service.

C57.166 supersedes four existing IEEE guides: C57.106 for mineral oil, C57.111 for silicone liquid, C57.121 for less-flammable hydrocarbon (LFH) liquid, and C57.147 for natural ester liquid. It also introduces synthetic ester liquid, which previously did not have its own IEEE acceptance and maintenance guide. The result is guidance that covers five insulating liquids—mineral oil, LFH, natural ester, synthetic ester, and silicone—within a common framework.

For transformer owners and laboratories, however, C57.166 should not be viewed simply as four older documents combined into one. Numerous technical changes were made during development. This article focuses primarily on how those changes affect the evaluation of in-service transformers.

A COMMON APPROACH TO IN-SERVICE LIQUIDS

One of the most useful changes is the establishment of a common philosophy for evaluating all five liquid types.

C57.166 emphasizes that no single liquid test should be used as the sole criterion for judging transformer condition. Results should instead be evaluated alongside historical trends, dissolved gas analysis (DGA), electrical testing, and the transformer’s overall condition. For example, treating poor-quality liquid without investigating an active gassing condition—or simply dehydrating the liquid when the transformer’s solid insulation is known to be wet—may fail to address the underlying problem.

The guide establishes three general conditions:

  • Condition I represents a liquid satisfactory for continued use.
  • Condition II applies primarily when dielectric breakdown voltage and/or water requirements are not met, and reconditioning, such as filtration or vacuum dehydration, may be appropriate. 
  • Condition III represents a more severely deteriorated liquid, particularly when properties such as interfacial tension, acid number, and power factor exceed the recommended limits.

These conditions previously existed for mineral oil and were labeled as classes, but they did not exist for the other four fluids. Now, they are also a part of the fluid evaluation and classification for the other four fluid types.

Another important feature is the consistent use of voltage class. The guide’s Table 4 establishes in-service thresholds for ≤69 kV, >69 kV to <230 kV, and ≥230 kV. This recognizes that acceptable liquid condition is not necessarily independent of the electrical stresses associated with the equipment in which the liquid is operating.

MINERAL OIL: FAMILIAR BUT AN IMPORTANT CHANGE

Mineral oil users will find many familiar values in C57.166 because the in-service limits in C57.106 were already well developed.

For example, C57.106 established ASTM D1816 dielectric breakdown limits of 23/40 kV at 1 mm/2 mm for equipment ≤69 kV; 28/47 kV for >69 kV to <230 kV; and 30/50 kV for ≥230 kV. It also established power factor limits of 0.5% at 25°C and 5.0% at 100°C, with IFT minimums of 25, 30, and 32 mN/m as voltage class increases. Those values are carried into the unified in-service table in C57.166.

One important change, however, is the disappearance of ASTM D877 from the transformer in-service limits. D877 is no longer an acceptable dielectric test for testing transformer fluids. This is because it has a poor correlation with predicting performance in an actual transformer.

C57.106 still included D877 in its Table 3. C57.166 uses ASTM D1816 for the dielectric breakdown evaluation of both unused and in-service mineral oil and explains that D1816 is more responsive to particles and dissolved water and therefore provides a better evaluation of changes occurring in transformer liquid.

The water limits for mineral oil remain familiar as well: 35 mg/kg (ppm) for equipment rated 69 kV and below; 25 mg/kg for the intermediate-voltage class; and 20 mg/kg for equipment rated 230 kV and above. C57.166 also notes that absolute water content is strongly influenced by liquid temperature and that percent saturation should be considered, particularly at lower temperatures. This is important when interpreting a sample rather than treating the reported ppm value as an isolated pass/fail measurement.

LESS-FLAMMABLE HYDROCARBON: A MAJOR EXPANSION

The changes for less-flammable hydrocarbon (LFH) liquids are more substantial.

C57.121-1998 provided essentially one set of acceptable service-aged values without differentiating among transformer voltage classes. Its Table 4 specified, among other values, D1816 dielectric breakdown minimums of 23 kV at a 1 mm gap and 34 kV at a 2 mm gap, a maximum power factor of 1.0% at 25°C, a maximum acid number of 0.20 mg KOH/g, a maximum water of 35 ppm, a minimum IFT of 24 mN/m, and a minimum 300°C fire point.

C57.166 places LFH liquids into the same voltage-class structure used for mineral oil.

For ≤69 kV equipment, the 2 mm D1816 minimum increases from 34 kV to 40 kV, and the IFT minimum increases from 24 to 25 mN/m. The 25°C power-factor limit is tightened from 1.0% to 0.5%. More importantly, the guide now establishes increasingly restrictive limits for the >69 kV to <230 kV and ≥230 kV classes. The dielectric values become 28/47 kV and 30/50 kV respectively, while IFT increases to 30 and 32 mN/m.

This is a meaningful change. The older LFH guide treated service-aged fluid largely as one class. C57.166 recognizes that the condition criteria appropriate for a lower-voltage transformer are not necessarily sufficient for higher-voltage equipment.

C57.166 also aligns the LFH acid-number and water limits with the voltage-specific values used for mineral oil. Acid number is limited to 0.20, 0.15, and 0.10 mg KOH/g as voltage class increases, while water is limited to 35, 25, and 20 mg/kg. The 300°C minimum fire point remains an important characteristic of the less-flammable classification. These changes give the owner a more detailed set of reference points for trending an LFH-filled transformer in service.

NATURAL ESTER: DEFINING IN-SERVICE LIMITS

Natural ester guidance has evolved considerably since C57.147-2018.

The earlier guide established dielectric strength and water limits by voltage class but acknowledged significant areas where sufficient service experience was not yet available. Most notably, C57.147 stated that there was insufficient field data analysis to establish reliable recommended limits for dissipation factor. The ≥230 kV values were also identified as provisional.

C57.166 removes that provisional status and provides a much more complete set of in-service criteria.

Natural ester now has a 25°C power factor limit of less than 3.0% for all three voltage classes. The guide also establishes IFT minimums of 10, 12, and 14 mN/m for ≤69 kV, >69 kV to <230 kV, and ≥230 kV equipment, respectively.

Acid number is also formally incorporated into the in-service limits: ≤0.5 mg KOH/g for ≤69 kV and ≤0.3 mg KOH/g for the two higher-voltage classes. Water limits remain 450, 350, and 200 mg/kg as voltage class increases. And C57.166 clearly establishes the continued-use criterion as a viscosity increase of ≤10% from the value measured before energization.

Taken together, these changes move natural ester evaluation beyond the more provisional approach found in the earlier guide and provide utilities and laboratories with a substantially more complete framework for interpreting in-service results.

The differences in allowable water content are particularly important when comparing natural ester with mineral oil. Natural ester can dissolve considerably more water, so the absolute ppm values should not be interpreted using mineral oil experience. C57.166 retains the higher natural-ester water limits while placing them in the same table with the other liquids. This makes the chemical differences visible to the user and reinforces the need to interpret each liquid according to its own characteristics rather than against a single universal set of limits.

SYNTHETIC ESTER: AN ENTIRELY NEW CATEGORY

Perhaps the most significant addition to C57.166 is synthetic ester.

The four predecessor guides contained no corresponding IEEE acceptance and maintenance guide for this liquid. C57.166 now places synthetic ester alongside the other major transformer insulating liquids and references ASTM D8240 for unused-liquid requirements.

The guide also provides useful background on why synthetic ester cannot simply be treated as either mineral oil or natural ester. Synthetic esters are manufactured by reacting a polyol with long-chain carboxylic acids, allowing properties to be tailored through the selection of starting materials. Because transformer synthetic esters are manufactured using saturated acids, they have high oxidation resistance. They also have a much higher water-saturation capability than mineral oil and may hold substantially more water while maintaining dielectric capability.

C57.166 now gives synthetic ester its own in-service limits. Dielectric breakdown follows the same D1816 voltage-class limits applied to mineral oil, LFH, and natural ester. Power factor is less than 3.0% at 25°C. IFT limits are ≥11, ≥14, and ≥16 mN/m, while acid-number limits are ≤1.0, ≤1.0, and ≤0.5 mg KOH/g as voltage class increases. Water limits are 450, 350, and 200 mg/kg.

This provides owners of synthetic-ester-filled transformers with an IEEE framework for routine liquid-condition assessment that previously did not exist in these acceptance and maintenance guides.

The inclusion of synthetic ester also affects routine laboratory practice. The guide identifies ASTM D1816 for dielectric breakdown, ASTM D924 for dissipation factor, ASTM D971 for interfacial tension, ASTM D974 for acid number, and ASTM D1533 for water content, while recognizing that some tests used for other liquids may not be applicable. That distinction is useful because synthetic ester now has defined IEEE reference values rather than requiring the owner or laboratory to extrapolate from mineral-oil or natural-ester guidance.

SILICONE: MODERNIZING OLDER GUIDANCE

Silicone presented a different challenge because C57.111 dated to 1989.

That document specified a 25 kV minimum dielectric breakdown value using ASTM D877, maximum water of 100 ppm, maximum power factor of 0.2% at 25°C, and maximum acid number of 0.2 mg KOH/g for service-aged silicone liquid.

C57.166 retains several of those fundamental condition indicators—most notably the 0.2% power factor, 100 mg/kg water, and 0.2 mg KOH/g acid-number limits for applicable silicone installations—but integrates silicone into the modern test-method framework, including D1816 as the approved dielectric test methodology.

The guide also recognizes that not every test used for hydrocarbon and ester liquids is appropriate for silicone. For example, the guide’s Table 4 lists IFT as not applicable. This is an important benefit of the unified format: The user can see not only different numerical limits, but also where applying the same test across every insulating liquid would be inappropriate.

USING C57.166 FOR IN-SERVICE TRANSFORMER EVALUATION

For users of the previous guides, the practical change is that acceptance and maintenance information for the major transformer insulating liquids is now available in one document and presented in a consistent format. Many established limits remain familiar, but C57.166 makes it easier to identify the appropriate tests and limits for each liquid type.

Mineral oil retains the established voltage-class approach with several updates to test practice. LFH liquids now have more detailed voltage-specific criteria. Natural ester includes defined limits for properties that previously had limited field data. Silicone is incorporated into the same framework, and synthetic ester is included with its own acceptance and in-service criteria.

For transformer owners, the guide’s Table 4 provides a direct reference for continued-use limits by liquid type and voltage class. The limits are reference points for evaluation and trending, not automatic removal-from-service criteria. Each case should be evaluated individually, and significant changes from previous test results should be investigated. It is critical that the lab selected to test transformer fluids can distinguish the thresholds for each fluid type. For example, as a service company, it will reflect poorly if a report is submitted that states natural ester fluid failed moisture with a 155 mg/kg (ppm) test value, when the acceptable value is 200 mg/kg or higher, depending on the voltage class. 

IEEE C57.166 provides an updated reference for evaluating insulating liquids in in-service transformers. Users familiar with C57.106, C57.111, C57.121, and C57.147 will recognize the technical foundation, but should review the new tables and liquid-specific guidance carefully. Several limits have changed, additional criteria have been established, and synthetic ester has been added as a separate liquid category. 

Scott Reed is CEO of MVA, a service company specializing in transformer oil testing and vacuum processing services. He is active in the IEEE Transformers Committee, where he serves as Vice Chairman. He is also Vice Chair of the IEEE C57.166 Working Group, and holds three U.S. patents. He has published numerous papers for NETA World and serves as an Expert Transformer Panelist at Power Test.  Reed earned a BS in electrical engineering from North Carolina State University.